Michael Polly
Royal Shell Real Estate
- Address : 959 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island,United States
About
Michael has earned the ePRO, Graduate Real Estate Institute (GRI) and is a licensed USCG Captain. Michael became the first Realtor in SW Florida and the 11th in the state to earn his Accredited Seller Representative (ASR). This designation is awarded based on both actual performance and required education. The first awarded in SW Florida. Michael has completed the education and training necessary to earn his Certified Property Valuator (CPV), only the second awarded in Lee County. He offers Broker Price Opinions as part of his advanced service to his clients. Most recently Michael has completed advanced training and work review and is now certified by National Valuations Standards Institute. Michael has also earned his (CDPE) Certified Distressed Property Expert to assist buyers and sellers with bank owned foreclosures and short sale properties. Michael worked for 15 years with UPS in a variety of roles. His training and management of projects helped him build his own business.
Contact
Sort by
- Price - High To Low
- Newest
- Lot area - High To Low
- Sqft - High To Low
- Favorites
▾
- Price - Low To High
- Price - High To Low
- Newest
- Lot area - Low To High
- Lot area - High To Low
- Sqft - Low To High
- Sqft - High To Low
- Favorites
$1,445,000
3Beds
2Baths
1,568Sqft
Naples, Florida, 34102, United States
Amazing opportunity in the hottest neighborhood in Naples- Lake Park! This picturesque remodeled home sits on a huge south facing lot on a quiet street and comes completely turnkey so you can move right in! Also, if you are lookin
Michael Polly
$1,445,000
1220 10th Avenue N
3Beds
2Baths
1,568Sqft
Naples, Florida, 34102, United States
Amazing opportunity in the hottest neighborhood in Naples- Lake Park! This picturesque remodeled home sits on a huge south facing lot on a quiet street and comes completely turnkey so you can move right in! Also, if you are looking to build in the future, please see the MHK renderings in the photos! With 3 bedrooms and den, 2 baths, and an open floor plan centered around a brand new kitchen, this home has everything you are looking for. The large screened in lanai off the living room is the perfect space to entertain in the evenings. The immense fenced in backyard has tons of room for a pool and play area to spare! The oversized 2 car garage has extra storage and the circular drive allows for easy access and extra parking. Less than a 1 mile walk/bike to the beach and 5th Ave S, enjoy the world class shopping and dining of the Design District & Downtown Naples. For more outdoor enjoyment walk 4 blocks over to Fleischman Park for pickleball or bike the Greenway to award winning Baker Park. Every possibility just a few steps from your new front door. This home has it all and is priced to sell.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,445,000
1220 10th Avenue N
3Beds
2Baths
1,568Sqft
$1,445,000
Naples, Florida, 34102, United States
$1,430,000
2Beds
2Baths
1,519Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Nestled in the world-renowned Sundial Resort and Spa this 2BR/2BA plus den condo is the perfect island getaway. Captivating tropical views are maximized throughout the inviting open living and dining area and kitchen due to condo location, which is top floor, and one condo back from the gulf. Tastefully furnished in a neutral décor. Dine, relax or watch the sunrise on the screened lanai.
Michael Polly
$1,430,000
1401 Middle Gulf Drive #405R
2Beds
2Baths
1,519Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Nestled in the world-renowned Sundial Resort and Spa this 2BR/2BA plus den condo is the perfect island getaway. Captivating tropical views are maximized throughout the inviting open living and dining area and kitchen due to condo location, which is top floor, and one condo back from the gulf. Tastefully furnished in a neutral décor. Dine, relax or watch the sunrise on the screened lanai. Marvel at the fantastic view of the Gulf of Mexico. Steps to private pool and pristine, shell-filled, calm-water beach. Sanibel Island is world famed as a beautiful seaside resort endowed with miles of unspoiled beaches and excellent sailing waters. World-class shelling, fishing, golf, bird watching and natural attractions complement the island lifestyle.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,430,000
1401 Middle Gulf Drive #405R
2Beds
2Baths
1,519Sqft
$1,430,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$1,400,000
6Beds
4Baths
4,819Sqft
Summerfield, Florida, 34491, United States
Rare Lake Weir Waterfront Compound Acreage Sandy Beach Minutes to Ocala & The Villages Discover a truly one-of-a-kind lakefront retreat on Lake Weir, offering the perfect blend of privacy, space, and Florida resort-style living. Set on 3.
Michael Polly
$1,400,000
10745 SE SUNSET HARBOR ROAD
6Beds
4Baths
4,819Sqft
Summerfield, Florida, 34491, United States
Rare Lake Weir Waterfront Compound Acreage Sandy Beach Minutes to Ocala & The Villages Discover a truly one-of-a-kind lakefront retreat on Lake Weir, offering the perfect blend of privacy, space, and Florida resort-style living. Set on 3.44 acres with 147 feet of pristine sandy beachfront, this gated waterfront estate delivers the rare opportunity to own acreage directly on the water—ideal for buyers relocating to Florida in search of sunshine, serenity, and year-round outdoor living. Surrounded by mature trees, lush landscaping, and peaceful water views, the property is designed as a private family compound or vacation retreat, featuring two fully furnished lake homes plus expansive guest accommodations. The residences include a charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home and a second 2-bedroom, 2-bath home with an attached garage, offering flexibility for multi-generational living, hosting guests, or income potential. A standout feature is the climate-controlled guest quarters above the four-car garage, currently used as a flex and game space, complete with tall ceilings, a wood-burning/gas fireplace, and a full bathroom—perfect for entertaining, extended stays, or creative use. The outdoor experience is unmatched, with a private dock, sandy swim beach, paved drive, RV carport, extensive concrete walkways, and multiple gathering areas to enjoy sunrise coffee or sunset views over the lake. This is true Florida lakefront living, where boating, swimming, fishing, and watersports become part of everyday life. Located just minutes from shopping, dining, and entertainment in The Villages and Ocala, and a short drive to the World Equestrian Center, this Lake Weir estate offers both convenience and tranquility. For those seeking a quiet waterfront lifestyle with easy access to modern amenities, this property delivers the best of both worlds. All homes convey fully furnished, making this a seamless move-in opportunity. Select recreational items—including a ski boat, Jet Ski, ATV, trailer, and water toys—may be negotiated separately. Whether envisioned as a primary residence, second home, multi-generational estate, or investment retreat, this exceptional Lake Weir waterfront compound is a rare offering in Marion County. Schedule your private showing today and experience the serenity, space, and sunshine of Lake Weir living.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,400,000
10745 SE SUNSET HARBOR ROAD
6Beds
4Baths
4,819Sqft
$1,400,000
Summerfield, Florida, 34491, United States
$1,399,000
6Beds
3Baths
3,141Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
3,141 sq. Ft. Custom built brick pool home on 3 acres located just down the street from the World Equestrian Center Ocala! The property boasts an updated main house with 5 bedrooms, detached guest casita with 1 bedroom & full bathroom, detached 4-car garage & screened-in pool.
Michael Polly
$1,399,000
7604 NW 14TH
6Beds
3Baths
3,141Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
3,141 sq. Ft. Custom built brick pool home on 3 acres located just down the street from the World Equestrian Center Ocala! The property boasts an updated main house with 5 bedrooms, detached guest casita with 1 bedroom & full bathroom, detached 4-car garage & screened-in pool. The private gated entrance leads to the main house & garage with plenty of parking & a large concrete pad for an RV, horse trailer or boat. There is no HOA & the 3 acres is fully fenced & ready for a horse barn to be built. The house has 2 primary suites both with ensuite full baths, 3 additional bedrooms, living room, dining room, & cozy family room with fireplace leading to the huge screened- in lanai. The kitchen has been updated with granite counter tops & stainless appliances plus the internal laundry room is over-sized with sink & shower. Throughout the house & casita you will find all wood laminate & tile flooring. The detached guest casita has a separate entrance with living room, bedroom & full bathroom. There is also a generator including in-ground propane tank. Well located within a quiet equestrian community, this property is move-in ready!
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,399,000
3Beds
3Baths
2,262Sqft
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
Experience elevated coastal living in this stunning 5th-floor waterfront residence offering 3 bedrooms plus a den and 3 full baths in the prestigious Dolphin Pointe at Waterside at Bay Beach. Positioned as a rare corner unit, this home provides enhanced privacy, abundant natural light, and captivating Gulf and Bay views from nearly every living space.
Michael Polly
$1,399,000
4137 Bay Beach Lane #556
3Beds
3Baths
2,262Sqft
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
Experience elevated coastal living in this stunning 5th-floor waterfront residence offering 3 bedrooms plus a den and 3 full baths in the prestigious Dolphin Pointe at Waterside at Bay Beach. Positioned as a rare corner unit, this home provides enhanced privacy, abundant natural light, and captivating Gulf and Bay views from nearly every living space. Designed for both comfort and entertaining, the open floor plan is complemented by elegant designer furnishings and expansive windows that frame the surrounding water views. The gourmet kitchen features stainless steel appliances, Cambria countertops, and a breakfast bar that flows seamlessly into the living and dining areas, creating a welcoming space for gathering and relaxation. Start each day with beautiful sunrises and unwind on the spacious screened lanai, where serene bay views and coastal breezes set the tone for relaxed Florida living. The primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with water views, a walk-in closet, and a spa-inspired ensuite bath with dual vanities, a jetted tub, and a separate shower. Additional living and dining areas provide flexibility for hosting guests or enjoying quiet evenings at home. Residents enjoy an exceptional lifestyle with resort-style amenities including beach access, community pool and spa, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, putting green, social room, guest suites for overflow of guests and additional storage. Ideally located on the south end of Fort Myers Beach, near Lovers Key State Park, marinas, dining, and shopping. This is a rare opportunity to own a beautifully appointed waterfront residence in one of Fort Myers Beach’s most desirable communities. Sold Turnkey with exclusions. Your paradise awaits!
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,399,000
4137 Bay Beach Lane #556
3Beds
3Baths
2,262Sqft
$1,399,000
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
$1,395,000
4Beds
4,861Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
This is the Florida home you have been waiting for… Conveniently located in the small, gated community of Herons Landing, this Architecturally Pleasing Florida-style home offers 4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms and a den (office) that can easily be a fourth bedroom. The interior is light, bright, and airy, with soaring vaulted ceilings.
Michael Polly
$1,395,000
1990 My Tern Court
4Beds
4,861Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
This is the Florida home you have been waiting for… Conveniently located in the small, gated community of Herons Landing, this Architecturally Pleasing Florida-style home offers 4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms and a den (office) that can easily be a fourth bedroom. The interior is light, bright, and airy, with soaring vaulted ceilings. Features a gourmet chefs kitchen with Bertch Cabinets, Quartz countertops and backsplash, a large 5’x10’ center island, illuminating under cabinet lighting, a designer range hood, Bosch induction cooktop /stove, dishwasher, and refrigerator. Beautiful engineered French oak hardwood throughout the living area adds to the open concept and spacious contemporary design. Perfect for entertaining with a dedicated dining room and spacious living area, large screen lanai, and open-air front porch. The sliding doors between the living area and screened lanai open completely. The Primary Suite is a luxurious retreat with a private bathroom featuring a marble shower and floors, Kohler fixtures, a freestanding bathtub, and a double sink vanity. Guests will feel pampered in the three luxurious bedrooms with an impressive hall bathroom complete with a marble walk-in shower and floors, double vanity, and Kohler fixtures. The laundry room has a stainless sink, garment steam system, and stackable washer and dryer. The lower level with finished energy efficient insulated ceiling offers an oversized garage for more than 3 cars and plenty of room for golf carts, bikes, kayaks, boat, and a workshop area. In 2023, many updates were completed, including a new metal roof, Pex plumbing, backflow valve, heat exchanger and programmable thermostat. 2024 improvements include hurricane-resistant PGT windows and doors, Hardie siding, new electrical panel and breakers, RainBird 4zone irrigation system, Aquasana whole-house water treatment, outdoor shower with hot & cold water, engineered hardwood floors, ceiling fans, level 5 smooth interior wall finish, new kitchen and bathrooms. Community amenities are conveniently located adjacent to the home, including rarely used resort-style pool, hot tub, pool bathrooms, abundant decking, outdoor furniture, and pickleball/tennis court. Enjoy the amenities without having to maintain your own. Homeowners have private deeded beach access for walking or riding bikes to Bowman’s Beach and a dock for kayaking or paddle boarding. This energy-efficient home has an excellent 4-point inspection report, low Florida insurance, and low utilities. It is a one-of-a-kind home and a must-see for the most discerning Buyer. This amazing property can be offered turn-key except for select personal items.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,395,000
4Beds
2Baths
2,146Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
This is the Florida home you have been waiting for… Conveniently located in the small, gated community of Herons Landing, this Architecturally Pleasing Florida-style home offers 4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms and a den (office) that can easily be a fourth bedroom. The interior is light, bright, and airy, with soaring vaulted ceilings.
Michael Polly
$1,395,000
1990 My Tern Court
4Beds
2Baths
2,146Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
This is the Florida home you have been waiting for… Conveniently located in the small, gated community of Herons Landing, this Architecturally Pleasing Florida-style home offers 4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms and a den (office) that can easily be a fourth bedroom. The interior is light, bright, and airy, with soaring vaulted ceilings. Features a gourmet chefs kitchen with Bertch Cabinets, Quartz countertops and backsplash, a large 5’x10’ center island, illuminating under cabinet lighting, a designer range hood, Bosch induction cooktop /stove, dishwasher, and refrigerator. Beautiful engineered French oak hardwood throughout the living area adds to the open concept and spacious contemporary design. Perfect for entertaining with a dedicated dining room and spacious living area, large screen lanai, and open-air front porch. The sliding doors between the living area and screened lanai open completely. The Primary Suite is a luxurious retreat with a private bathroom featuring a marble shower and floors, Kohler fixtures, a freestanding bathtub, and a double sink vanity. Guests will feel pampered in the three luxurious bedrooms with an impressive hall bathroom complete with a marble walk-in shower and floors, double vanity, and Kohler fixtures. The laundry room has a stainless sink, garment steam system, and stackable washer and dryer. The lower level with finished energy efficient insulated ceiling offers an oversized garage for more than 3 cars and plenty of room for golf carts, bikes, kayaks, boat, and a workshop area. In 2023, many updates were completed, including a new metal roof, Pex plumbing, backflow valve, heat exchanger and programmable thermostat. 2024 improvements include hurricane-resistant PGT windows and doors, Hardie siding, new electrical panel and breakers, RainBird 4zone irrigation system, Aquasana whole-house water treatment, outdoor shower with hot & cold water, engineered hardwood floors, ceiling fans, level 5 smooth interior wall finish, new kitchen and bathrooms. Community amenities are conveniently located adjacent to the home, including rarely used resort-style pool, hot tub, pool bathrooms, abundant decking, outdoor furniture, and pickleball/tennis court. Enjoy the amenities without having to maintain your own. Homeowners have private deeded beach access for walking or riding bikes to Bowman’s Beach and a dock for kayaking or paddle boarding. This energy-efficient home has an excellent 4-point inspection report, low Florida insurance, and low utilities. It is a one-of-a-kind home and a must-see for the most discerning Buyer. This amazing property can be offered turn-key except for select personal items.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,395,000
1990 My Tern Court
4Beds
2Baths
2,146Sqft
$1,395,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$1,375,000
4Beds
3Baths
2,515Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Introducing “Beach Therapy,” a sophisticated coastal retreat in Beachview Country Club Estates on Sanibel Island that seamlessly blends refined island living with exceptional investment potential. This impeccably maintained four-bedroom, three-bath residence offers both immediate income generation and an elegant private escape.
Michael Polly
$1,375,000
1251 Par View Drive
4Beds
3Baths
2,515Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Introducing “Beach Therapy,” a sophisticated coastal retreat in Beachview Country Club Estates on Sanibel Island that seamlessly blends refined island living with exceptional investment potential. This impeccably maintained four-bedroom, three-bath residence offers both immediate income generation and an elegant private escape. Thoughtfully designed for comfort and effortless entertaining, the home showcases a spacious, open-concept floor plan enhanced by light-filled living areas, a gracious family room, and an inviting sunroom. Coastal-inspired interiors, curated finishes, and a serene color palette create a timeless aesthetic, while a well-appointed bunk room provides flexible accommodations for guests and extended family. The outdoor living experience is equally compelling, featuring a private screened lanai with a heated pool and desirable southern exposure, delivering abundant natural light throughout the day. This tranquil setting offers the perfect backdrop for relaxed afternoons or intimate gatherings, embodying the essence of resort-style living. Ideally positioned to enjoy Sanibel Island’s world-renowned shelling beaches, scenic bike paths, inshore and offshore boating and fishing, this exceptional property captures the true spirit of coastal luxury. With its generous accommodations, and turnkey appeal, “Beach Therapy” represents a rare opportunity to acquire a distinctive island residence with both lifestyle and investment appeal and offers a short walk to a private deeded beach access.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,375,000
1251 Par View Drive
4Beds
3Baths
2,515Sqft
$1,375,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$1,350,000
5,000Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
This offering presents a rare opportunity to acquire a stabilized single-tenant industrial investment in Fort Myers, Florida. The property is secured by an absolute NNN lease structure, providing passive income with zero landlord responsibilities. The lease features 4% annual rent escalations, creating a built-in hedge against inflation and long term income growth.
Michael Polly
$1,350,000
11575 Marshwood Lane
5,000Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
This offering presents a rare opportunity to acquire a stabilized single-tenant industrial investment in Fort Myers, Florida. The property is secured by an absolute NNN lease structure, providing passive income with zero landlord responsibilities. The lease features 4% annual rent escalations, creating a built-in hedge against inflation and long term income growth. The asset is further strengthened by a brand new 5-year lease term and personal guaranty, providing security and predictability for investors. The property consists of 0.47 acres with a functional industrial layout and strong tenant utility, making it an attractive passive investment opportunity.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,350,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
This offering presents a rare opportunity to acquire a stabilized single-tenant industrial investment in Fort Myers, Florida. The property is secured by an absolute NNN lease structure, providing passive income with zero landlord responsibilities. The lease features 4% annual rent escalations, creating a built-in hedge against inflation and long term income growth.
Michael Polly
$1,350,000
11575 Marshwood Lane
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
This offering presents a rare opportunity to acquire a stabilized single-tenant industrial investment in Fort Myers, Florida. The property is secured by an absolute NNN lease structure, providing passive income with zero landlord responsibilities. The lease features 4% annual rent escalations, creating a built-in hedge against inflation and long term income growth. The asset is further strengthened by a brand new 5-year lease term and personal guaranty, providing security and predictability for investors. The property consists of 0.47 acres with a functional industrial layout and strong tenant utility, making it an attractive passive investment opportunity.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,349,900
3Beds
3Baths
3,030Sqft
Cape Coral, Florida, 33914, United States
Life is Too Short, Why Not Have Everything You Want & Deserve! Looking for Move-In Ready Gulf Access Home, Tastefully Decorated with Curated Furniture & Accessories, Needing 3000 Sq Ft to Spread Out, Desire a Resort Style Pool & S
Michael Polly
$1,349,900
123 SW 54th Street
3Beds
3Baths
3,030Sqft
Cape Coral, Florida, 33914, United States
Life is Too Short, Why Not Have Everything You Want & Deserve! Looking for Move-In Ready Gulf Access Home, Tastefully Decorated with Curated Furniture & Accessories, Needing 3000 Sq Ft to Spread Out, Desire a Resort Style Pool & Spa, Dreaming of Gorgeous Travertine Flooring & Must have 3-Car Garage to store all your Toys? STOP LOOKING, Your Search is Over!!! Explore this Beautifully Crafted, 1-Owner Home Constructed from the Finest Materials (2013), No Details were Overlooked. The Functional Floor Plan consist of 3 Bedrooms, 3 Full Baths, 3030 sq ft of Living Space, Office, Family, Formal Living & Dining Rooms, Dinette area overlooks the Lanai & Pool Deck. Owners Retreat is Separate from the Guest Bedrooms, offering Total Privacy for Guest & their Host. Primary Bathroom has Dual Vanities, a Luxurious Jetted Soaking Tub & Walk-In Shower w/Multi Heads. Kitchen Features High-End SS Appliances, Brand New 48 JennAir Refrigerator, Butlers Pantry & Custom Wood Cabinets w/Granite Counters. Living Areas feature Soaring Ceilings w/Beautiful Trays & Crown Molding, 8 Interior Doors, Custom Window Treatments, Sonos Music, Security System w/Cameras, Brand New AC System, & so much more. 3-Car Garage has plenty of Height for additional Storage & even includes a 7000# Car Lift! Multiple Sliders lead out to your Brick Paver, Covered Lanai. Theres Ample Seating Areas for Outside Dining & Entertaining, a Built In Grill for BBQs & a Heated Pool & Spa. Boaters will Love this Prime Location, offering Direct Access, No Bridges & only mins to the River!! Boat Dock w/Plastic Decking, 18K Lift & Canopy included. Bike or Walk to Nearby Rotary Park & Tarpon Point Marina. Home is Priced to Sell & Offered Fully Furnished w/just a few Personal Items Excluded. Transferable Flood Policy under 1000, No Flooding or Hurricane Damage!!! What more could you Want or Need? Call today to schedule your Private Tour before this one is gone!
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,349,900
123 SW 54th Street
3Beds
3Baths
3,030Sqft
$1,349,900
Cape Coral, Florida, 33914, United States
$1,345,000
3Beds
2Baths
1,653Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Welcome to this beautifully designed and coastal inspired canal home on Sanibel Island. A perfect east end location which is nestled on a wide canal with quick access to the Gulf of Mexico. This gorgeous open concept floor plan offers the ultimate in island living.
Michael Polly
$1,345,000
930 Lindgren Boulevard
3Beds
2Baths
1,653Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Welcome to this beautifully designed and coastal inspired canal home on Sanibel Island. A perfect east end location which is nestled on a wide canal with quick access to the Gulf of Mexico. This gorgeous open concept floor plan offers the ultimate in island living. A perfect for a vacation home or full time living residence! You will love the spacious and inviting family room, soothing primary bedroom with the spa like bathroom featuring a walk-in shower and free standing bathtub, two comfortable and private guest bedrooms, well-appointed guest bathrooms, good storage and a two car garage. Fully updated including all impact windows and doors, a newer metal roof, new A/C and tropical landscaping. The custom kitchen offers a large island, lots of cabinets, Quartz/grantie countertops, stainless appliances, and a separate dining room for entertaining. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully planned Step outside to a refreshing pool, large screened lanai, and a delightful dock where your neighbors are dolphins and manatees. A short walk to the beach or park in the deeded beach parking lot. Sanibel is known for its fabulous bike paths, boating & water sports, world class shelling, white sandy beaches, azure waters, themed restaurants, quaint shops, abundant wildlife, and a quiet, low-key atmosphere.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,345,000
930 Lindgren Boulevard
3Beds
2Baths
1,653Sqft
$1,345,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Favorite this home
Enter your email to continue
or
By signing in you agree to UniqueHomes Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
Loading properties...